Gas vs Electric Water Heater: Ultimate Comparison

When deciding between a gas or electric water heater, it's important to consider various factors to make an informed choice. Energy efficiency is a key consideration, as gas water heaters are generally more efficient and have lower operating costs. However, electric water heaters may have lower upfront costs. The availability of natural gas and the cost of utilities in your area should also be considered. Installation requirements differ, with gas water heaters requiring proper venting, while electric models do not. Maintenance needs can also vary, with gas water heaters potentially requiring more maintenance. Assessing these factors and seeking professional advice can help you determine the best option for your home and preferences.

How do electric water heaters work?

An electric water heater relies on heating elements submerged in a storage tank to heat the water. These elements are powered by your home's electrical system. The thermostat on the unit regulates the water temperature and turns off the heating elements when the desired temperature is achieved. This ensures a constant supply of hot water for your needs.

Benefits of electric water heaters

Electric water heaters offer a host of benefits over traditional gas-powered heaters:

  • Ease of Installation: Electric water heaters are generally easier to install since they do not require a gas line or venting system. This simplifies the installation process and reduces associated costs.

  • Safety: Electric water heaters eliminate the risk of gas leaks or carbon monoxide poisoning, providing a safer option for households.

  • Efficiency: Electric water heaters are highly efficient, as they convert nearly all the energy consumed into heat for the water. This can result in lower energy bills and reduced environmental impact.

  • Versatility: Electric water heaters can be installed in various locations, including areas without access to natural gas. They offer flexibility in terms of placement within the home.

  • Lower Maintenance: Electric water heaters typically require less maintenance compared to gas-powered models. They do not have burners or pilot lights that need regular cleaning or adjustment.

  • Quieter Operation: Electric water heaters operate quietly without the noise generated by gas burners or fans.

  • Cost-Effective: Electric water heaters often have a lower upfront cost compared to gas-powered models, making them a more affordable option for homeowners.

  • Durability: Electric water heaters are known for their durability and longer lifespan, requiring fewer repairs or replacements.

Disadvantages of electric water heaters

Despite their many advantages, electric water heaters, like everything else, have some drawbacks you should consider as well.

  • Slower recovery rate: One disadvantage of electric water heaters is their slower rate of water heating compared to gas models. This can result in longer wait times for hot water, especially during times of high demand.

  • Energy costs: While electric water heaters are generally more energy-efficient, the cost of electricity can still contribute to higher energy bills. It's important to consider the ongoing expenses of electricity when assessing the overall cost-effectiveness.

  • Shorter lifespan: Electric water heaters tend to have a shorter lifespan compared to their gas-powered counterparts. This means you may need to replace the unit sooner, which can add to the long-term costs of ownership.

  • Power outage impact: Electric water heaters rely on a continuous supply of electricity to operate. During power outages, there will be no hot water available until power is restored, which can be inconvenient.

How do gas water heaters work?

Gas water heaters operate by igniting a gas burner located at the bottom of a large tank. The burner heats the water stored in the tank, which can be accessed through faucets or other outlets. As hot water is used, cold water enters the tank to replace it, maintaining a continuous supply of hot water. This process allows for immediate access to hot water whenever it is needed in the household.

Pros of gas water heaters

Gas water heaters are a popular choice for many homeowners:

  • Cost-effectiveness: Gas water heaters are generally more cost-effective in the long run, as they can result in lower utility bills compared to electric units. Gas is often a more affordable fuel source, leading to potential cost savings over time

  • Faster hot water delivery: Gas water heaters heat water more quickly than electric models, providing hot water faster when you turn on the tap. This can be beneficial for households that require immediate access to hot water.

  • Longer lifespan: Gas water heaters tend to have a longer lifespan compared to electric units. This means you may not need to replace them as frequently, saving you money on replacement costs.

Cons of gas water heaters

Despite their many advantages, gas water heaters also have some potential downsides:

  • Environmental impact: Gas water heaters contribute to air pollution as a result of burning natural gas, which is a fossil fuel. This combustion process releases pollutants into the atmosphere, adding to overall environmental concerns.

  • Risk of explosion: Incorrect installation or improper usage of gas water heaters can potentially lead to explosions. It is crucial to strictly follow safety guidelines and have a professional handle the installation to ensure proper operation and minimize the risk of accidents.

  • Higher maintenance costs: Gas water heaters generally require more maintenance compared to electric units. This may involve regular inspections, cleaning, and potential repairs. These additional maintenance requirements can lead to higher ongoing costs.

  • Longer installation time: Installing a gas water heater typically takes more time compared to electric units. It involves setting up gas lines, venting systems, and ensuring proper connections. Allowing for several hours of installation time is important to ensure a satisfactory and safe setup.

Are electric water heaters energy-efficient?

The efficiency of electric water heaters can vary depending on various factors such as the size of the unit, the quality of insulation, and the operating temperature. While gas-powered water heaters are commonly known for their higher efficiency, electric models have been improving their energy efficiency ratings over time. With advancements in technology, electric water heaters are becoming more energy-efficient, offering homeowners the potential for cost savings on their utility bills. It is important to consider the specific energy efficiency ratings of different electric water heater models to make an informed decision based on your energy consumption needs and environmental considerations.

Are gas water heaters energy-efficient?

Gas-based water heaters generally offer better cost-effectiveness and energy efficiency compared to electric models. These water heaters operate by burning natural gas to heat the water, which typically consumes less energy compared to electric heaters. The energy efficiency of a gas water heater can be influenced by factors such as the size and model of the unit, as well as proper maintenance practices. Investing in a high-efficiency gas water heater and ensuring regular maintenance can further enhance its energy efficiency, resulting in potential cost savings on utility bills. It is recommended to consider the specific energy efficiency ratings and features of different gas water heater models to make an informed decision based on your energy consumption needs and priorities.

What does it cost to buy and install electric water heaters?

Electric water heaters are available in various sizes and configurations, offering flexibility to homeowners. The cost of an electric water heater can vary depending on factors such as the capacity, brand, and features. On average, a 50-gallon electric water heater may cost between $300 and $800. It's important to consider both the upfront cost of the unit and the installation expenses when budgeting for a new electric water heater.

The installation of an electric water heater typically involves additional costs, which can vary based on factors such as the complexity of the installation, any necessary electrical upgrades, and local labor rates. On average, the installation of an electric water heater can range from $300 to $500. It's advisable to consult a licensed plumber or professional installer to obtain accurate cost estimates and ensure a proper and safe installation.

Additionally, it's important to factor in any potential additional expenses, such as permits or additional materials, that may be required for the installation. By considering both the upfront cost of the electric water heater and the installation expenses, homeowners can make an informed decision and budget accordingly.

What does it cost to buy and install gas water heaters?

Gas water heaters are available in various sizes and price ranges to accommodate different household needs. On average, the cost of a gas water heater ranges from $500 to $1,500, with higher-end models reaching up to $3,000. It's important to consider both the upfront cost of the unit and the installation charges when budgeting for a gas water heater.

In addition to the cost of the unit, installation charges can vary depending on factors such as the location, existing plumbing infrastructure, and any necessary modifications. It's recommended to consult with a licensed plumber or professional installer to obtain accurate cost estimates and ensure a proper and safe installation.

While the initial cost of a gas water heater may be higher compared to other types, it's important to consider the long-term benefits and savings. Gas water heaters offer better energy efficiency, which can result in lower utility bills over time. Additionally, they provide a reliable and continuous supply of hot water, making them suitable for households with high hot water usage or specific needs.

By considering both the initial cost and the long-term savings, homeowners can make an informed decision and choose a gas water heater that meets their requirements and budget.

Maintenance needs of electric water heaters

To ensure the reliable and safe operation of your electric water heater, it's important to prioritize regular maintenance. Here are some key maintenance tasks to keep in mind:

Check the temperature and pressure relief valve regularly.

Flush the tank periodically to remove sediment buildup.

Inspect and clean the heating elements as needed.

Ensure secure and undamaged electrical connections.

Seek professional assistance for complex maintenance tasks or issues.

Maintenance needs of gas water heaters

Regular maintenance is essential for gas water heaters to ensure safe and efficient operation. Tasks such as annual tank flushing, periodic inspection of the anode rod, regular monitoring of the burner and pilot assembly, annual testing of the temperature and pressure relief valve, and checking for gas leaks are important. Seek professional assistance if needed.

Safety considerations of electric water heaters

Safety should be a top priority when using an electric water heater to prevent potential hazards. Proper grounding and adherence to manufacturer's instructions are crucial to minimize the risk of electrocution and fire hazards. It is advisable to have a licensed professional handle the installation to ensure safety and reliability.

Safety considerations of gas water heaters

Safety is paramount when using a gas water heater. To ensure a safe environment, it is important to take several precautions. These include installing a carbon monoxide detector near the water heater, regularly inspecting and maintaining the unit, keeping the area clear of flammable materials, familiarizing yourself with the emergency shut-off valve, and following the manufacturer's instructions for safe operation. By implementing these measures, you can minimize the risk of potential hazards and promote a safe environment in your home.

How to choose between electric vs gas water heater

By taking these factors into consideration, you can make a well-informed decision regarding the most suitable type of water heater for your specific needs.

  • Home size and hot water usage: Determine the appropriate capacity based on the size of your household and the frequency of hot water usage.

  • Cost: Compare the initial purchase and installation costs of electric and gas water heaters. Gas heaters may offer long-term cost savings, while electric heaters have lower upfront expenses.

  • Efficiency: Gas water heaters are generally more energy-efficient and cost-effective to operate compared to electric models.

  • Maintenance: Electric water heaters require less maintenance, while gas heaters need regular inspections to ensure safety and prevent malfunctions.

  • Environmental impact: Electric water heaters produce fewer emissions and have a lower carbon footprint compared to gas water heaters.

In the end, selecting the right water heater is a personal decision based on your preferences, lifestyle, and budget. Take into account factors such as energy efficiency, installation costs, maintenance requirements, and the availability of fuel sources in your area. Evaluate your hot water needs, consider long-term cost savings, and take into account any specific environmental considerations. By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision that meets your priorities and ensures a dependable supply of hot water for your home.

Why you should hire a licensed professional

to install your water heater

Installing or replacing a water heater is a significant undertaking that should be treated with care. While attempting a do-it-yourself approach may seem tempting to save money, it can be risky and potentially hazardous. It is strongly advised to enlist the services of a licensed and experienced professional for this task. They possess the necessary knowledge, skills, and expertise to ensure a safe and proper installation. By relying on a professional, you can have peace of mind knowing that safety protocols will be followed and any potential issues will be addressed. Your safety should always take precedence, and entrusting the job to a licensed professional is the wise and responsible choice.

Be sure to do your research

When selecting a water heater, conducting comprehensive research is crucial. Both electric and gas models have their advantages and disadvantages, and it's important to consider factors such as safety, efficiency, and installation requirements. By thoroughly evaluating these aspects, you can find the perfect water heater for your specific needs. However, it's vital to highlight the importance of engaging a licensed professional for the installation process. Their expertise and knowledge will ensure that your water heater is installed correctly and operates safely and efficiently.

Contact Us

One of the most significant investments you can make in your home is a water heater replacement.



Baca Specialty Services, Heating and Cooling HVAC
Sante Fe, NM 87508